Social Security is NOT Congress’ Rainy Day Fund

Social Security is NOT Congress’ Rainy Day Fund

The past several years, we’ve seen an alarming legislative trend:

Asking young Americans to trade their future Social Security benefits for repaying their student loan debt.

Asking new parents to trade their future Social Security benefits for parental paid leave.

And now, suggesting the next COVID-19 pandemic stimulus comes from Social Security.

SSRN-id3580533

In this most recent proposal, put forth by members of the American Enterprise Institute and the Stanford Graduate School of Business, the authors examine the possibility of issuing the next round of direct payments in return for deferred Social Security benefits.

Proponents of the idea call it a deficit-free stimulus measure. Unlike the Economic Impact Payments issued in May, letting Americans borrow against their retirement benefits would function more like a loan than direct stimulus. Since borrowers would effectively repay the loan by pushing back their retirement age—and ultimately receiving less lifetime Social Security benefits—supporters tout the idea as deficit-neutral.

Mathematically, that’s true. In 30, 40, or 50 years when the young workers most likely to apply for this direct payment will reach retirement age.

But what about right now?

Right NOW, the Social Security Trustees project the Social Security Trust Fund will fail to be able to pay full scheduled benefits by 2035. In just 15 years.

And keep in mind: 15 years was the estimate the Trustees reported BEFORE the Coronavirus recession. This estimate does NOT include data related to corporate bankruptcy, business closures, mass lay-offs, and rising unemployment. With so many workers and their employers no longer contributing to the Trust Fund (and likely filing for early retirement to regain their lost income), it’s unrealistic to think Social Security’s solvency isn’t being affected.

Long-term mathematics aside, what would asking potentially millions of Americans bearing the weight of our economic burden to cash out their Social Security benefits early do?

It would take an already insolvent program and drain unspeakable amounts of money from it, putting current day and near-future retirees at even more risk than they are right now. Our present day Social Security beneficiaries rely on the program RIGHT NOW. It makes no difference to them whether the “loans” young Americans take out now get paid back in 30 years.

There are other valid criticisms of tempting young workers with immediate relief for their immediate problems. Who among us looks back on their decision-making at age 20 and doesn’t wish we could have known what we know now?

If those people exist, they’re certainly in the vast minority. Most young workers worry about saving to buy a car, a home, paying off their schooling, or just finding a way to pay for rent, bills, and food on a small income. With decades of working life ahead of them, retirement is a vague and faraway concept. A lot of young people don’t even believe Social Security will be there for them when they retire. So, why wouldn’t they cash out now if they’re suffering hardship? Even if they may be completely shooting themselves in the foot farther down the road?

But the most glaring problem with this idea should this: why is the only idea Congress can put forth to solve our nation’s ills draining money out of Social Security?

Social Security is not some Rainy Day Fund for Congress to tap when Americans need help. And if it IS a Rainy Day Fund, it’s the one millions of Americans have created for themselves to use when they choose to retire. It’s Congress’ responsibility to help us work through our problems—not to make us choose between being suffering now or suffering later.

And they NEED to remember those who are in no position to make these choices for themselves. Our retirees today are being abandoned by these proposals. They don’t benefit from new options to control student loan debt, take time off to raise children, or receive this kind of stimulus. But they will definitely lose when the income they depend on gets slashed into ribbons.

Even if retirees DID support measures like this: there just isn’t enough money. Full stop.

Like the previous two incarnations of this policy, it is very unlikely a measure like this—if it was to become a bill—would ever pass into law. Very few people want to see anything come out of their Social Security that isn’t Social Security-related.

The alarming thing is even with everything happening right now—with seniors being the most at-risk group, both medically and economically—there is no stopping our elected officials from thinking Social Security is a limitless credit line. Nothing more than a giant piggy bank.

These proposals have to stop.

New opportunities to bridge the generation gap

New opportunities to bridge the generation gap

Social isolation among senior citizens is a growing concern. After all, growing older can be a lonely time for many aging Americans. But different programs are popping up to help battle this loneliness. UBRC’s, or University-based retirement communities, bring senior citizens onto college campuses. Living amongst the college community, going to classes and participating in… Continue Reading

8 great places to retire in America

8 great places to retire in America

When most people think of moving in retirement, Florida is the first place that comes to mind. Warm temperatures, sunny days and a large 50+ community… what’s not to like? But Florida isn’t for everyone. Maybe you’d like to stay closer to family. Or maybe you actually like the change of seasons. Money recently compiled… Continue Reading

2020 Presidential candidates’ proposed changes to Social Security

2020 Presidential candidates’ proposed changes to Social Security

With the 2020 election looming on the horizon, presidential campaign are in full swing. To help track the candidates and their positions on Social Security, the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College has put together a list comparing the various plans. Compiling where each candidate stands into one chart makes it easy to compare… Continue Reading

What to look for when reviewing your Social Security statement

What to look for when reviewing your Social Security statement

You can check your Social Security statement easily by logging onto the Social Security Administration’s website (www.ssa.gov/mysocialsecurity). But do you know what you should be looking for? A recent article in USA Today highlighted 6 items to keep in mind while reviewing your statement. The statement you’re looking at is your estimated benefits if you… Continue Reading

Take the 7-day sugar challenge

Take the 7-day sugar challenge

The average American eats about 17 teaspoons of added sugar each day — way above the recommended average for men, women or children. Just in time to coincide with New Years resolutions, the New York Times has come out with a 7-day sugar challenge. Each day of the challenge shows participants a different way to… Continue Reading

Sugar — too much or too little — could be the cause behind your headaches

Sugar — too much or too little — could be the cause behind your headaches

Many people know that too much sugar can be a contributing factor to headaches, but did you know too little sugar can be a culprit as well? “Sugar-related headaches come from a rapid swing in your blood sugar level,” Dr. Anisha Patel, DO of Medical Offices of Manhattan A recent article by Popsugar explains how… Continue Reading

What you need to know for 2020

What you need to know for 2020

With a new year comes change and some of those changes could affect your retirement plans, Social Security and Medicare. MarketWatch has put together a quick reference of what you should know before 2020 hits. The article highlights changes you can expect to your 401(k) savings, average Social Security payment and Medicare premiums, to name… Continue Reading